Back to briefingCommon Ground

World

Washington ranch couple fined $267,540 over ponds as appeals court weighs jury-trial question

The Washington state Department of Ecology fined Wade and Teresa King, owners of King Ranch in Grant and Douglas counties, $267,540 in 2023 for allegedly damaging regulated wetlands by digging ponds. The Kings argue the areas are long-standing stockwater ponds for their livestock, not regulated wetlands.

The department's required process directed the Kings to the PCHB, an administrative panel that does not provide jury trials. A judge dismissed their lawsuit, ruling they first had to complete the administrative process. A Washington Court of Appeals commissioner paused the PCHB proceedings in September while the court considers whether the Kings are entitled to a jury trial.

Oliver Dunford, a senior attorney at Pacific Legal Foundation representing the Kings, said they are prepared to petition the U.S. Supreme Court if they are unsuccessful in Washington. The Kings' attorneys estimate the cost of complying with the department's orders could exceed $3.7 million.

Compare how each perspective frames this story

Sources 1