Back to briefingCommon Ground

World

Sotomayor says she hopes the court will take back some crazy things, and counts the immunity case among them

Justice Sonia Sotomayor said she is hoping the court will take back some of the crazy things that it has done, then said she was only joking — maybe not. In her words, there are some opinions she hopes will get overturned in her lifetime, and the immunity case is one of them.

The remarks came at a weekend civics education event at George Washington's Mount Vernon estate, where the liberal justice singled out the court's landmark 2024 presidential immunity ruling. That ruling, in Trump v. United States, held that former presidents have absolute immunity from criminal prosecution for actions within their core constitutional powers, at least presumptive immunity for other official acts, and no immunity from prosecution for unofficial conduct.

Justices Samuel Alito and Clarence Thomas are both in their late 70s, which is raising questions about their potential retirements and whether a Democratic-controlled Senate could complicate Trump's efforts to replace them with fellow conservatives. Sotomayor said there are some norms we may have lost forever, but that she does not think we will fail as a democracy.

Compare how each perspective frames this story

Sources 1