Back to briefingCommon Ground

Politics

Michigan's Proposal 2 draws a federal First Amendment lawsuit from the Mackinac Center

Proposal 2, a ballot initiative that Michigan voters approved, was pitched to them as a way to curb pay-to-play donations and get money out of politics. The measure has also triggered a federal First Amendment lawsuit, which alleges that its separate speech and disclosure provisions could ensnare journalists, nonprofits and policy researchers who discuss elected officials.

The Mackinac Center for Public Policy filed the lawsuit and says it is not challenging the initiative’s central pay-to-play restrictions on political contributions from utility companies and government contractors. Its suit instead targets reporting and disclosure requirements for certain communications that refer to candidates or "promote, support, attack or oppose" candidates or ballot questions, even when voters are not expressly urged to support or oppose them.

Michiganders for Money Out of Politics, also known as MOP UP Michigan, said the lawsuit was expected after voters approved Proposal 2. Campaign manager Maura Cowley said the group is "confident Proposal 2 will withstand legal scrutiny".

The lawsuit also challenges Proposal 2’s expansion of the definition of an election-related "expenditure": the amended definition includes public communications that "promote, support, attack, or oppose" a candidate or ballot question, whether or not they expressly advocate for or against the outcome. Under the revised committee definition, an organization that spends at least $500 on such expenditures could be treated as a political committee if the state determines the spending was intended to influence voters.

Compare how each perspective frames this story

Sources 1