Back to briefingCommon Ground

World

Voters in five states approve bans on noncitizen voting, while measures in California and Arizona fail

Voters in five states overwhelmingly approved ballot measures barring noncitizens from voting. Federal law already prohibits noncitizens from voting in federal elections, but the measures passed in Kansas, Alaska, Arkansas, South Dakota and West Virginia clarify or explicitly codify citizenship requirements for state and local elections. Support exceeded 60% in each state.

Election integrity advocates pointed to the results as evidence supporting President Donald Trump and Republicans’ argument that their push to require proof of citizenship for federal voter registration has "overwhelming bipartisan support." Hans von Spakovsky, a former member of the Federal Election Commission and senior legal fellow of Advancing American Freedom, applauded the passage of the ballot measures but warned they could prove ineffective unless states are allowed to verify voters’ citizenship.

Related election measures failed in California and Arizona, with California’s Proposition 39 defeated 58.5% to 41.4%. Jason Snead, executive director of Honest Elections Project, said Arizona’s measure was broader legislation that included several provisions beyond noncitizen voting, which may have contributed to its defeat.

The conservative-majority Supreme Court prepares to consider a related dispute over whether Arizona can require proof of citizenship on its state voter registration form and remove suspected noncitizens from the rolls before an election. A ruling could affect how states enforce citizenship requirements.

Compare how each perspective frames this story

Sources 1