Back to briefingCommon Ground

Politics

Alaska judge rules Peltola campaign’s request for rejected absentee ballot data “not reasonable”

A judge in Alaska ruled Wednesday that the request by Democratic U.S. Senate candidate Mary Peltola’s campaign for a list of absentee voters whose ballots have been rejected is “not reasonable,” particularly given the time crunch election officials face. Counting continues in the ranked vote election, in which Peltola and two-term Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan are the main contenders; Alaska’s is the only Senate race in the country that remained too early to call.

The campaign’s attorneys sued state elections officials last Friday, seeking the list of voters with rejected absentee ballots and the reasons for the rejections; they said their intent was to ensure that all qualified voters have their ballots counted. Attorneys for the state said the information would violate voter privacy and that producing such a list from a voter database would be an “electronic service or product” that state law says may not take priority over an agency’s main responsibilities.

In a written ruling, Superior Court Judge Thomas Matthews said that “in theory” voter database records could be redacted and produced. He added that the division is not required to disclose what the campaign requested, because the records “cannot reasonably be produced at this juncture, nor redacted of confidential information.”

Abha Khanna, an attorney for the campaign, said in Tuesday arguments that the campaign wasn’t seeking to disrupt ballot counting, and argued the information sought is a matter of public record. Michaela Thompson, who oversees the absentee ballot review boards for the division, said in an affidavit that the division’s “old, inflexible” database cannot produce a report excluding confidential addresses, so the agency would have to work with a vendor.

Compare how each perspective frames this story

Sources 1