Back to briefingCommon Ground

World

Study of IRS conservation easement reviews finds large cuts to appraised values; former IRS valuator describes pressure

A new study is raising questions about whether the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) has been putting its finger on the scale to hit American landowners with higher tax bills through a little-known conservation tax program.

Conducted by Infinity Advisory Services, the study looked at more than 130 IRS valuation reviews. In 115 conservation easement tax incentive cases with comparable figures, it reports the agency slashed taxpayers’ appraised values by an average of roughly 97%. The study makes the case that the pattern across properties, tax years and reviewers points to a process designed to reach a predetermined answer.

A former IRS valuator, speaking to Fox News Digital, said he experienced officials pressuring appraisers to reach predetermined conclusions. In one Cleveland case, according to the study, a donated preservation easement went from between $18.1 million and $23.2 million to $400,000 in a follow-up review by the same IRS reviewer.

Compare how each perspective frames this story

Sources 1